開放式遊戲開發

来自Ashes of Creation Wiki
跳到导航 跳到搜索

Intrepid Studios has embraced an open (transparent) development approach, rather than sharing information through carefully curated press releases and announcements.[1]

Player feedback is important, however the identity and the vision of the game is not up for discussion; and so when we talk about the core systems and tenets and philosophies behind what the game that we're trying to make is, we believe that the game we are trying to make resonates with a large enough section of the MMORPG player base that it is a sustainable and profitable venture for us to create that core game. Now, the ancillary systems that live around the core philosophy of Ashes of Creation, or the subtleties and what we need to do in order to make a particular system or feature better... that we want to collect player feedback.[3] – Steven Sharif
  • Some game aspects will be more polished than others before they are presented.[7]
The delicate blend between a transparent development process, but also understanding that [the] majority of your player audience will not grasp, or will not take into context, what a work in progress looks like. So certain things we have to polish to the point where they're presentable; where they can be understood- again in its own context without my verbal support or Margaret's verbal support.[7] – Steven Sharif
I think that we live in an age where it's easy to be transparent if you're not trying to hide something. The downside is if you're showing something that's not a completed or finished product, it is incumbent upon the viewer to understand that fact.[1] – Steven Sharif
  • The purpose of transparent development is to enable participation and feedback from the community without the need to purchase access.[8]
The whole purpose of our development process being transparent being open is that you don't have to buy a package actually to participate. You can be a voice from the community. You can observe people playing. You can give your experiences and feedback.[8] – Steven Sharif
I don't answer to a board. I don't answer to a publisher. We answer to our players; and we try to be as transparent as possible with showing our progress; and showing it in a timely manner.[9] – Steven Sharif
  • Certain aspects of the game will not be revealed early to avoid spoilers.[10][11]
There are obviously going to be some aspects of the development that we will not reveal, like lore and some system mechanics in order not to spoil the game for release.[10] – Steven Sharif

設計

傳統上為人熟悉的 MMO 設計有兩種不同遊戲循環：「主題樂園」和「沙盒」。現時大多數的 MMO 都屬於「主題樂園」– 這種遊戲會引導玩家沿着特定路線遊玩，一如既往的任務樞紐之間會設有一個個景點，但甚少會出現分岔路，令玩家幾乎沒有自由成長的空間。近來新上市的 MMO 有的採取沙盒模式，儘管沙盒有極高的自由度，但是由於遊戲世界內沒有預設的內容，也沒有人為的開發，很多玩家會感到意猶未盡，簡單來說就像只有一大堆「沙」。很多玩家因此經常陷入兩難，要不選擇重復性高的主題樂園，不然就是荒無人煙的沙盒，而 Ashes of Creation 的節點系統正是將這兩者連接的橋樑。[12]

為了讓沙盒的機制變得有意義，遊戲裏必須有精心策劃的內容來伴隨玩家的決擇。意思就是，作為遊戲開發，我們必須創造「主題盒」式內容，應對玩家所選的每一條遊玩路線。[13] – Steven Sharif

設計概念

Ashes of Creation 的設計遵循五大概念支柱。[14]

  1. 引人入勝、親歷其境的故事
  2. 動態世界
  3. 玩家互動
  4. 玩家主導
  5. 風險與回報

Ashes of Creation 每項設計都遵循五大支柱：引人入勝及親歷其境的故事、動態的世界、玩家互動、玩家主導及風險與回報。玩家在遊戲裏的所有活動都與這些概念有關聯，公會所有的活動、伺服器整體的活動都能讓世界變得有新鮮感、常變、以及最重要的是...刺激。[14]

靈感

此翻译可能已过时

Ashes of Creation 的靈感源自數款 MMORPG。[15]

天堂II 很多系統的設計都圍繞着現時 MMORPG 失去了的概念：風險與回報。「風險愈大，潛在回報愈大」這種想法完全是一個「典範轉移」，是從每個人都是贏家、參與就有獎、恭喜你是遊戲的一員這些無聊的想法轉移。這些想法對營造玩家達成目標的渴望感，或失敗時的挫折感都毫無用處，但渴望感和挫折感正是玩家玩遊戲的動力。新遊戲壽命短不是沒有原因，它們總想與魔獸世界競爭。你不須成為「WoW 殺手」，你可以專注在設計哲學上的突破，而我認為這正是現今很多開發公司不願意冒險做的事情。[16] – Steven Sharif

對於前人的經驗，我們正在探索哪個遊戲有甚麼做得最好，然後當作靈感。力求推動這個領域，推陳出新，然後帶進二十一世紀。[15] – Jeffrey Bard

End-game

此翻译可能已过时

Ashes of Creation 將不會有一般的 end-game 階段。[17]

整個節點體驗的一部分是，由於世界每天都不斷改變，遊戲不是有真正的 eng-game 階段。遊戲開始第二個月將比第一個月非常不同，這是老玩家和新玩家同時經歷的體驗。[17] – Jeffrey Bard

我們希望這是個充滿活力的遊戲，即是所有內容永遠都不會過時。我們盡可能讓升級過程的體驗和 end game 體驗相同。我們認為為了讓玩家在遊戲不同階段都可以得到最大的樂趣，升級過程的體驗至關重要。[18] – Sarah Flanagan

內容膨脹

I have a very very very clear vision of all of the systems designs mechanics that are present within the game and we're sticking to that vision and we're not adding additional features and prolonging the development due to that scope creep.[19] – Steven Sharif

Pay to win

Ashes of Creation will not be pay to win.[20][21][22]

Ashes of Creation will not be pay to win, that is our pledge to the community. One of the core principles we set forth with Ashes of Creation is a very strong desire to maintain the game's even playing field.[22]
A lot of developers and companies have come along in the past- and I've been hit by this too- and they've said we're not going to have pay-to-win and then boom they roll out some pay-to-win. We have consistently said we won't be pay-to-win and in the pre-orders that we provide and even in the Kickstarter there were absolutely zero pay-to-win components whatsoever. So not only will we talk the talk but we will walk the walk as well.[21] – Steven Sharif
Because we are a non-box purchase game, meaning there is no box price to play Ashes of Creation, it is only a subscription; and that's beneficial because it reduces the barrier of entry and we want a high population obviously; but at the same time one of the ways we augment the revenue flows to sustain constant updates and new chapter releases and additional content within the game is through a cosmetic-only marketplace; and that means absolutely no pay-to-win whatsoever; and that will be adhered to forever.[20] – Steven Sharif

库存 slots, 隨機性 loot boxes and XP potions are considered pay-to-win.[23][24][25][26]

We will not use a loot box system for cosmetics either. We currently have a cosmetic store that offers limited time, limited quantity items to help sustain game development. These items are purely decorative and do not offer any in-game benefits.[23]
My definition of pay-to-win is really anything that affects the in-game economy, the in-game action pool, your abilities and/or skills... In my opinion the inventory slots and the XP potions would be considered pay-to-win.[25] – Steven Sharif
  • Items sold in the store that are also obtainable through gameplay are still considered pay-to-win.[30]
It undermines an achievement when you remove the need to achieve it.[30] – Steven Sharif
Q: Will there be RNG boxes?
A: I dislike RNG. Archeage made me loath rng monetization gimmicks.[26] – Steven Sharif

代理商

Intrepid Studios will self-publish Ashes of Creation in the NA (North American), OCE (Oceanic) and SEA (Southeast Asia) regions.[31][32]

We have learned a lot from our partnership with MY.GAMES, and we wish our friends there all the best as we have mutually decided to part ways. Looking ahead, we’re excited to announce that Intrepid Studios will be opening European offices in Amsterdam to help support our publishing operations in the EU/CIS regions. We have recently posted open positions for our new EU offices, and look forward to hiring the best and brightest in true Intrepid fashion.[33] – Steven Sharif

The Ashes of Creation MMORPG will not be published on the Steam platform.[34]

在地化/翻譯

此翻译可能已过时

Ashes of Creation 起初將支持英文、法文、德文和俄文。[36][37]

  • 意大利文、波蘭文和西班牙文將於稍後時間追加。[37]
    • 西班牙文將於近期追加。[38]
  • 官方正考慮追加其他語言。[36]

選擇伺服器將不受語言限制。[39]

There's localization that will be present in the German and French Russian languages to start; and then we intend to also localize in Italian, Polish and Spanish. So servers will be allocated within the region as being one of those language type servers. So it's not going to be per country per se as it might be per language.[37] – Steven Sharif

官方將致力翻譯 Ashes of Creation 成多種語言。[39][40]

遊戲平台

Ashes of Creation will be released on the Windows PC platform.[42][43]

Q: Will the upgrade to UE5 affect the supported systems? A lot of people are like linux question mark.[42]
A: It's something that we'll evaluate in the future. I haven't ruled it out necessarily- would see how much work it would take to do that, but really like less than one percent of the player base is using Linux.[42] – Steven Sharif

遊戲效能

遊戲效能 optimization when rendering 1300 simulated actors utilizing merged materials and meshes in Unreal Engine 5 Nanite.[45] This test was confirmed post-stream to be running on a RTX 3070.[46]

What you're seeing here showcases the new modular appearance component which can combine any set of meshes and materials into a single mesh and single material at run-time. What you're looking at is over 1300 different entities, different actors. These are simulated players essentially. Previously you saw the example they were just standing still. There was no animation, there was no effects, there was no environment and it was a thousand. This is thirteen hundred playing animations, playing effects, plus the environment which is Nanite in this example. So what you're seeing is all of these players moving around and doing something and you're seeing the frame rate at about 30 on Clayton's rig.[47] – Steven Sharif

Here you see that the FPS in the top right corner is like seven or eight on average, so not too good from a rendering perspective... So by merging now you can see that the same thousand players who are wearing the same armors as previously are actually having a 300 percent increase- 300 to 400 increase- in the performance of the of the FPS. So it went from 7 to about 21 on average and that is a significant optimization point that obviously this is just the beginning of the optimization efforts.[48] – Steven Sharif

Ashes of Creation was performing at 50-60 FPS on a 1080 Ti during early Alpha-1 testing.[49]

  • A "default player appearance" may be automatically applied during sieges or other large scale battles to improve client-side performance.[53][54][52]
I think you guys will agree with me here that effects now are, as opposed to where they were in Alpha-1, we've taken into account what people's feedback were, although it was always the case we were going to address them; and we've implemented them in such a way where they're more conducive to large player battles.[50] – Steven Sharif

Alpha 測試系統需求

Alpha-1 stress testing, March 17, 2021.[55]

These are fully operational NPCs. They have behavior trees, they have AI blackboards; they are functioning as an NPC would; and to my surprise, to everyone's surprise actually, the server handled it quite well: 5000 entities all within a very dense area.[56] – Steven Sharif

Minimum and recommended computer specifications for Alpha-2.[57]

Minimum Specs - 1080p
  • Processor: Intel i5 8400 | AMD Ryzen 5 2600
  • Memory: 12GB
  • Graphics: NVIDIA GTX 1070 or equivalent
  • DirectX: Version 12
  • Network: Broadband Internet connection
  • Storage: 100GB SSD Storage
  • Windows 10/11
Recommend Specs - 1440p
  • Processor: Intel i7 8700 | AMD Ryzen 5 3600
  • Memory: 16GB
  • Graphics: NVIDIA RTX 3070 or equivalent
  • DirectX: Version 12
  • Network: Broadband Internet connection
  • Storage: 100GB SSD Storage
  • Windows 10/11
Please note that these requirements will change throughout our testing phases.[57]

Unreal Engine 5

Unreal Engine 5 walkthrough.[58]

Lumen has done a great job in really bringing to to life this area. As you can see, there's light bouncing off of the surfaces and casting into the rest of the cave... I love how you can also see the detail in the costume and the cloth that we have now.[58] – Steven Sharif

unreal-engine-logo.png

Unreal Engine 5 is the graphical engine for Ashes of Creation.[58][59] The game was originally developed in Unreal Engine 4.[60] Migrating to UE5 early is expected to save time the long run compared to upgrading closer to release, or post-release.[61][62]

What it provides in my opinion as person who enjoys PvP is it adds additional dynamics to what is possible from your opponent or from yourself. You know, if there is a ledge and jumping off that ledge is going to deal a lot of damage to me when I hit the ground and that puts me at a significant disadvantage, maybe I have an option to jump off the ledge at a point where I can mantle onto the side of a cliff or something. Now the give and take there is I won't be able to use my skills while I'm mantled. I won't be able to react easily, but I didn't have to take the fall damage per-se. Or if there's an obstruction and I'm going to take a significant reduction in speed so that I can crouch and make it past that, and now I have a effective line of sight has been obstructed as a result of that decision. I think it adds interesting elements to the battlefield and the key here is going to be making sure that it's not cumbersome- that it doesn't feel opposite of the flow of combat.[65] – Steven Sharif
Lumen is going to greatly improve the visual fidelity and performance of the game with the reduced work and effort that's required by the art team, making Ashes of Creation much more beautiful than in UE4.[67] – Steven Sharif
Nanite brings us really an entirely new approach to rendering and art workflows. Now we can render more actors with extremely high detail while eliminating the need to bake out normal map textures. For artists essentially what this means is that they can import high quality sculpted meshes directly into Unreal 5 without really having to reduce the poly count, making the workflow more efficient while simultaneously improving the quality of the art.[70] – Steven Sharif
  • Features (such as World partitions and One file per actor) make it much easier for multiple developers to work together.[61]
    • World partitions also enable Unreal Engine 5 maps to exceed the map size constraints of UE4 (~20 kilometers squared).[61]
Q: How does this upgrade to UE5 affect the Ashes of Creation release timeline?[61]
A: While UE4 is a great engine, there are certain focuses and technological endeavors that Epic is doing on UE5 that won't necessarily be supported by UE4; and we want to make sure given the lifespan of Ashes and how long we intend this MMO to last, that when we made this decision early on during the development process that we weren't going to exacerbate the amount of effort it would take to move over later in the lifespan or after launch.[61] – Steven Sharif
  • As of January 24, 2022 all teams have moved over to Unreal Engine 5.[74]
    • The developers were able to transition to Unreal Engine 5.1.1 in February 2023 as part of milestone 4.[75][76][77]
    • The upgrade to Unreal Engine 5.2 was completed. The developers expect to start upgrading to 5.3 around the end of 2023.[78][79]
    • At some point the developers intend to stop updating Unreal Engine until post-launch. This decision will be based on careful consideration of potential delays and other risks.[80]
Q: What is your stance in regards to focusing on delivering an MVP versus continuously upgrading your tools and engine to deliver a better product with new tech, even if that results in delays or additional years of development like UE 5.2, maybe 5.3 etc?
A: Our technical teams, especially our network team, our ICS teams, our gameplay engineering teams, they convene and weigh when our next update should be on the engine side: What new technologies might bring benefit overall. My perspective on how we balance the need for integration of new technology versus the responsibility we have in a timely manner to provide testing sessions that get us closer to the launch date; that's a delicate balance. I would say generally our disposition is not to incorporate new technologies that yield some significant amount of delay on the development side. We very much take the perspective that we're capable of adjusting and/or integrating those new technologies post-milestone, post-launch if necessary. At some point we'll stop updating the Unreal Engine in development until launch. That point hasn't come yet, but of course the larger the project grows and on the more custom we make the engine for our back-end needs; and for whatever else merge conflicts can occur- those mergers can become big and painful; and the update process gets more painful. So to answer your question shortly, we have a team that evaluates what direction we need to take there; and at the top of my mind is always, let's not incorporate delays as a result of leveraging new technologies.[80] – Steven Sharif

伺服器

The world will be the same on each server, but 節點 will develop differently. Different servers will have different narratives. Things that happen on one server may not happen on another.[81][82][13]

To answer your question about "what stops all servers from from progressing the same nodes," the answer to that question is "other players." Certain content is locked behind different nodes that develop. If we assume that at some point all of the information regarding node progression is available, not all players on a server may agree on what content they want access to, or that they want other players to have access to. Even if a certain perks from node progression are considered "best value" to players trying to solve a node meta, that doesn't mean all players on a server benefit from that in the same way. Because of this, some players make act against your best interests, because it isn't their best interest. Nodes define (and redefine) the world around you, influence points of interest, world quest lines, story arcs, drop tables, resource pools, and even spawn tables for NPCs and bosses. The cycle of nodes leveling and triggering events is something we expect to see play out in a variety of different ways, across different servers, based on how players choose to play Ashes of Creation.[81] – Ry Schueller
  • There will be a multitude of servers located throughout the various regions of the world.[84]
    • Server selection will show the region where the server is located and/or the ping to that server.[84]
With regards to live launch when the server's go live, you'll be selecting a server to play on; and that will be your character's home; and that server you'll be aware of where that server is located usually by either a ping or a region that's notated on next to the server.[84] – Steven Sharif

地區

Ashes of Creation will launch with the following server regions:[87][88]

At this stage we do not have numbers on how many different servers will exist for different regions. We've said in the past 8-10,000 concurrent users per server is what we'd like to aim for. Obviously, the number of servers that exist in a region are going to be dependent on the population that's playing.[95] – Steven Sharif

Other server regions will be considered based on interest.[89][88]

  • South America is under consideration due to traffic from that region.[96]

Once we get closer to launch we'll update this information, which may include additional regions.[89]

Certain regions will have "harmonized" subscription prices that better reflect their local economies. These regions will be segregated from other regions.[97]

  • Players will be able to make characters on any server they wish. There will be no region locking (outside of harmonized regions).[98]

Folks have always been able to make characters on any server they wish. We are not region locking anyone.[98] – Margaret Krohn

伺服器種類

  • There won't be separate PvE and PvP servers but some servers may be more PvP focused than others.[99][100][101]

插件/模組

Addons, DPS meters, and threat meters will not be supported.[103][104][105][106]

My decision is not to allow DPS meters nor add-ons. I feel we have adequate measures in place to prevent a majority of potential third party trackers. I know this subject has passionate voices on both sides and I respect the various opinions and positions many of you have expressed.[105] – Steven Sharif
  • The developers do not want addons/mods to be necessary to experience the game.[107]
  • The developers believe that DPS meters (parsers) can cause toxicity and other negative behaviors.[104][108][106]
What role DPS meters provide in online communities that I've noticed in the past my experiences: they can be a bit toxic, they can be a bit exclusionary; and that's why we don't want the DPS meters.[104] – Steven Sharif
Meters in my opinion are a removal from the game immersion; and what I mean by that isn't necessarily even the fact that having the meter takes you out of the game per-se, but it is- there's a lot of diegetic approach that you can take that doesn't rely on UI elements like a meter to indicate how you should do a thing; and when you're not utilizing those types of meters you can do different types of strategies and encounter design. You can have things that can be more subtle and aren't going to be immediately given away by a meter indicating something; and that's the type of gameplay that we think that I believe we want to emphasize; and for that reason, we're not going to be including threat meters. What we will be including however are animation indicators. We're going to be including ability indicators to show the tank "hey I might be losing aggro here." I'm observing in the world these immersive elements that are not tied to any specific type of UI, but indicate to me that this monster might be moving off to attack somebody else in a very immediate future; and now I should be using the abilities that I'm saving to regain that aggro, or to lock them down with a taunt or something. That to me is a bit more representative of the type of gameplay we want to to bring in our encounter design.[104] – Steven Sharif
info-orange.png以下某些信息最近尚未得到开发人员的确认，可能不在当前的开发路线图上。
  • There will be integrations available for streaming services such as Twitch and a few other services, but it's not something that will be exposed through an API just yet.[109]
  • The design of the game API is still under consideration.[110]

戰鬥記錄

There are combat logs in Ashes of Creation.[111]

We will be providing combat data for individual players in their chat window, that players can filter and analyze for themselves. The goal is to mitigate and make the practice less prevalent through the ease that DPS meters provide. Also to place actionable enforcement for players who attempt to circumvent the decision by use of 3rd party programs, for which we will be monitoring.[112] – Steven Sharif

里程碑

December 2015 First team members were hired.[113]
February 2016 Ashes of Creation design documentation and prototyping.[114][113]
December 10, 2016 Official website was launched and project announced.[113]
January 18, 2017 Official discord was launched.[115]
May 2, 2017 Kickstarter crowdfunding campaign launched with $750,000 funding goal.[116]
June 3, 2017 Kickstarter crowdfunding campaign completed with 19,576 backers raising $3,271,809.[117]
June 2017 Game production began with a team size of 15-20.[114]
June 21, 2017 夏季众筹 campaign launched.[118]
July 22, 2017 Summer crowdfunding campaign completed with 2,485 backers.[119]
September 1, 2017 PAX West 2017.[120][121]
November 4, 2017 Raised $16,500 for Extra Life children's hospitals.[122]
December 15, 2017 Alpha-0 released on schedule.[123]
March 19-23, 2018 Game Developers Conference (GDC) 2018.[124]
April 5, 2018 PAX East 2018.[125]
August 15, 2018 Last day for purchases of Alpha-1 through Intrepid pre-order packs.[126]
August 20, 2018 At Gamescom with My.com.[127]
August 27, 2018 100 developers working on Ashes of Creation.[128]
September 1, 2018 PAX West 2018 panel.[129]
October 19, 2018 Ashes of Creation Apocalypse battle royale (previously called Alpha-1 phase 1 battlegrounds).[130]
November 4, 2018 Raised $20,518 for Rady Children's hospital with Extra Life.[131]
April 15, 2019 60 developers working on Ashes of Creation at San Diego offices (following disengagement with Malaysian art team).[132]
November 3, 2019 Raised $20,901 for Rady Children's hospital with Extra Life.[133]
August 21, 2020 Announced a mutual parting of ways with publisher My.games.[33]
October 17, 2020 Almost 3,000,000 registered accounts for Ashes of Creation.[134]
October 17, 2020 ~87 developers working on Ashes of Creation.[135]
November 8, 2020 Raised $88,546 for Rady Children's hospital with Extra Life.[136]
February 26, 2021 Official ashesofcreation.com website redesign.[137]
May 5, 2021 Alpha-1 sales resumed with the announcement of the Adventurer 預購禮包.[138]
May 17, 2021 Verbal NDA was lifted from Alpha-1 testing.[139]
July 9, 2021 Alpha-1 no-保密協議 preview weekend began on schedule.[140]
July 11, 2021 Alpha-1 no-保密協議 preview weekend completed on schedule.[141]
July 14, 2021 Alpha-1 no-保密協議 month long test began on schedule.[142][143]
August 15, 2021 Alpha-1 no-保密協議 month long test completed on schedule.[144]
November 7, 2021 Raised $34,485 for Rady Children's hospital with Extra Life.[145]
December 23, 2021 Announced that Ashes of Creation is moving to Unreal Engine 5.[58][59]
January 14, 2022 Over 120 people working on Ashes of Creation.[146]
November 5, 2022 Raised $77,939 for Rady Children's hospital with Extra Life.[147]
August 31, 2023 Over 150 people working on Ashes of Creation.[148]
November 5, 2023 Raised $76,964 for Rady Children's hospital with Extra Life.[149]
December 19, 2023 Over 170 people working full-time on Ashes of Creation.[150][151]
March 1, 2024 188 employees working on Ashes of Creation.[152]

成就

  • Kickstarter资助最多的MMORPG.[153]
  • Kickstarter的第7位最多资金的视频游戏.[154]
  • 最值得期待的MMO – MMORPG.com的2017年最佳奖项.[155]
  • MMORPG.com的2017年最佳奖项 – MMOs World.[156]
  • Gamescom 2018: 最佳独立游戏.[157]
  • Gamescom 2018: 最佳在线游戏.[157]
  • 2020年最佳独立MMO – massivelyop.com reader's poll.[158]
  • 2021年及以后最值得期待的MMO – massivelyop.com读者投票.[159]

其他

引用

  1. ↑ 1.0 1.1 A chat with Ashes of Creation's Steven Sharif, 2017-06-7.
  2. ↑ 直播, 2023-07-28 (1:30:11).
  3. ↑ 3.0 3.1 直播, 2023-04-07 (55:22).
  4. ↑ 直播, 2023-03-31 (1:00:16).
  5. ↑ 直播, 2022-10-28 (32:52).
  6. ↑ 直播, 2017-06-01 (37:39).
  7. ↑ 7.0 7.1 直播, 2022-04-29 (21:00).
  8. ↑ 8.0 8.1 直播, 2021-12-23 (1:23:41).
  9. ↑ 訪談, 2018-10-20 (3:43:52).
  10. ↑ 10.0 10.1 transparency.png
  11. ↑ 直播, 2018-05-04 (39:41).
  12. ↑ A reactive world - Nodes.
  13. ↑ 13.0 13.1 MMOGames interview, January 2017
  14. ↑ 14.0 14.1 design pillars.png
  15. ↑ 15.0 15.1 15.2 15.3 15.4 15.5 訪談, 2018-08-24 (8:35).
  16. ↑ 16.0 16.1 訪談, 2020-07-29 (9:02).
  17. ↑ 17.0 17.1 影片, 2018-04-05 (40:08).
  18. ↑ February 8, 2019 - Questions and Answers.
  19. ↑ 直播, 2020-07-25 (1:31:44).
  20. ↑ 20.0 20.1 直播, 2020-11-30 (56:02).
  21. ↑ 21.0 21.1 直播, 2020-07-25 (1:53:46).
  22. ↑ 22.0 22.1 kickstarter p2w.png
  23. ↑ 23.0 23.1 23.2 loot-boxes.png
  24. ↑ 24.0 24.1 直播, 2020-07-25 (48:28).
  25. ↑ 25.0 25.1 Podcast, 2018-08-04 (1:57:56).
  26. ↑ 26.0 26.1 RNG boxes.png
  27. ↑ 訪談, 2021-06-13 (48:27).
  28. ↑ steven-multi-boxing-3.png
  29. ↑ steven-multiple-accounts.png
  30. ↑ 30.0 30.1 steven-pay-to-win-items.png
  31. ↑ steven-publishing-oce-sea.png
  32. ↑ 訪談, 2018-08-21 (11:20).
  33. ↑ 33.0 33.1 33.2 Blog: New Adventure Awaits.
  34. ↑ ashes-steam.png
  35. ↑ apoc-offline.png
  36. ↑ 36.0 36.1 What languages will Ashes of Creation be in?
  37. ↑ 37.0 37.1 37.2 37.3 訪談, 2018-08-24 (2:35).
  38. ↑ spanish.png
  39. ↑ 39.0 39.1 39.2 直播, 2017-05-17 (1:09:22).
  40. ↑ 40.0 40.1 直播, 2017-05-24 (45:49).
  41. ↑ 訪談, 2018-08-24 (3:19).
  42. ↑ 42.0 42.1 42.2 42.3 42.4 直播, 2021-12-23 (48:45).
  43. ↑ 43.0 43.1 直播, 2017-05-26 (38:30).
  44. ↑ 直播, 2017-05-24 (23:50).
  45. ↑ 直播, 2021-12-23 (1:10:09).
  46. ↑ RTX3070clarification.png
  47. ↑ 直播, 2021-12-23 (1:08:42).
  48. ↑ 直播, 2021-09-24 (52:48).
  49. ↑ alpha-1-fps.png
  50. ↑ 50.0 50.1 直播, 2023-04-28 (1:03:41).
  51. ↑ 直播, 2023-01-27 (1:07:12).
  52. ↑ 52.0 52.1 直播, 2018-08-17 (1:07:51).
  53. ↑ 直播, 2020-07-25 (54:10).
  54. ↑ 直播, 2019-11-22 (1:08:05).
  55. ↑ steven-a1-stress-test.png
  56. ↑ 直播, 2021-03-26 (12:34).
  57. ↑ 57.0 57.1 What are the minimum and recommend computer specifications for Alpha Two?
  58. ↑ 58.0 58.1 58.2 58.3 影片, 2021-12-23 (0:00).
  59. ↑ 59.0 59.1 直播, 2021-12-23 (19:59).
  60. ↑ unreal.jpg
  61. ↑ 61.0 61.1 61.2 61.3 61.4 61.5 61.6 直播, 2021-12-23 (40:53).
  62. ↑ 直播, 2021-12-23 (50:50).
  63. ↑ 直播, 2021-12-23 (49:39).
  64. ↑ 直播, 2021-12-23 (42:09).
  65. ↑ 65.0 65.1 直播, 2021-12-23 (55:32).
  66. ↑ 影片, 2021-12-23 (23:53).
  67. ↑ 67.0 67.1 67.2 直播, 2021-12-23 (54:00).
  68. ↑ 68.0 68.1 直播, 2021-12-23 (52:52).
  69. ↑ 69.0 69.1 影片, 2021-12-23 (2:54).
  70. ↑ 直播, 2021-12-23 (52:58).
  71. ↑ 直播, 2023-10-31 (1:37:17).
  72. ↑ 直播, 2017-05-03 (26:50).
  73. ↑ 直播, 2021-12-23 (47:51).
  74. ↑ 直播, 2022-01-28 (7:26).
  75. ↑ 直播, 2023-03-31 (1:10:30).
  76. ↑ 直播, 2023-02-24 (1:14:41).
  77. ↑ 直播, 2023-01-27 (1:07:46).
  78. ↑ steven-ue5.jpg
  79. ↑ 直播, 2023-04-07 (1:21:29).
  80. ↑ 80.0 80.1 直播, 2023-03-31 (1:27:15).
  81. ↑ 81.0 81.1 roshen servers.png
  82. ↑ 直播, 2017-05-19 (37:03).
  83. ↑ Official Livestream - May 4th @ 3 PM PST - Q&A
  84. ↑ 84.0 84.1 84.2 直播, 2018-09-27 (48:13).
  85. ↑ 85.0 85.1 直播, 2021-11-19 (52:35).
  86. ↑ 直播, 2023-01-27 (4:18).
  87. ↑ 訪談, 2017-05-08 (22:06).
  88. ↑ 88.0 88.1 直播, 2017-05-24 (40:50).
  89. ↑ 89.0 89.1 89.2 89.3 89.4 89.5 server-locations.png
  90. ↑ 90.0 90.1 na and eu servers.jpg
  91. ↑ 91.0 91.1 91.2 91.3 Ashes of Creation FAQ: Where will your servers be?
  92. ↑ 92.0 92.1 servers SEA OCE.png
  93. ↑ steven-oce-servers.png
  94. ↑ Reddit Q&A, 2019-01-8.
  95. ↑ 直播, 2018-04-8 (AM) (26:41).
  96. ↑ 直播, 2018-07-09 (47:54).
  97. ↑ 直播, 2020-07-25 (1:21:03).
  98. ↑ 98.0 98.1 margaret-region-locking.png
  99. ↑ 直播, 2024-03-29 (2:27:46).
  100. ↑ 直播, 2017-05-12 (24:52).
  101. ↑ MMORPG Interview, 2016-12-12.
  102. ↑ 直播, 2017-05-10 (35:27).
  103. ↑ 訪談, 2023-09-10 (34:51).
  104. ↑ 104.0 104.1 104.2 104.3 104.4 直播, 2023-02-24 (1:19:29).
  105. ↑ 105.0 105.1 Ashes of Creation Forums - No Damage Meter?
  106. ↑ 106.0 106.1 直播, 2017-05-10 (20:02).
  107. ↑ 訪談, 2018-10-20 (6:29).
  108. ↑ 直播, 2020-04-30 (1:28:19).
  109. ↑ 訪談, 2018-05-11 (49:03).
  110. ↑ 直播, 2017-05-10 (21:41).
  111. ↑ Ashes of Creation Forums - No Damage Meter?
  112. ↑ Ashes of Creation Forums - No participation trophy.
  113. ↑ 113.0 113.1 113.2 MASSIVELY OP interview: Ashes of Creation on a new way to MMO.
  114. ↑ 114.0 114.1 steven-milestones.png
  115. ↑ Ashes Discord.png
  116. ↑ Ashes of Creation Kickstarter campaign
  117. ↑ Ashes of Creation Kickstarter.
  118. ↑ Summer Crowdfunding.png
  119. ↑ summerended.png
  120. ↑ PAX West 2017 Schedule.
  121. ↑ PAX West 2017 Map.
  122. ↑ Intrepid Studios Dev Team.
  123. ↑ 直播, 2018-01-18 (2:48).
  124. ↑ GDC.png
  125. ↑ PAX East.png
  126. ↑ Newsletter, 2018-08-7
  127. ↑ gamescom.png
  128. ↑ Ashes of Creation Gamescom 2018 Interview: Responding to Criticism.
  129. ↑ Newsletter, 2018-08-7
  130. ↑ alpha1-phase-1-update.png
  131. ↑ Intrepid Studios Extra Life 2018 (@MediaAoC).
  132. ↑ 訪談, 2019-04-15 (5:09).
  133. ↑ extralife2019.png
  134. ↑ 訪談, 2020-10-17 (18:36).
  135. ↑ 訪談, 2020-10-17 (56:55).
  136. ↑ extralife2020.png
  137. ↑ 直播, 2021-02-26 (9:51).
  138. ↑ Ashes of Creation Store: May cosmetics.
  139. ↑ steven-a1-verbal-nda.png
  140. ↑ Ashes of Creation Twitter - Alpha-1 Preview Weekend Begins
  141. ↑ steven-a1preview-end.png
  142. ↑ toast-a1-launch.png
  143. ↑ Guide to Alpha One.
  144. ↑ alpha-1-end.png
  145. ↑ extralife2021.png
  146. ↑ 訪談, 2022-01-14 (9:11).
  147. ↑ extralife2022.png
  148. ↑ 直播, 2023-08-31 (2:16:45).
  149. ↑ extralife2023.png
  150. ↑ Steven Sharif Christmas message, 2023.
  151. ↑ 直播, 2023-12-19 (1:32:23).
  152. ↑ steven-employees.png
  153. ↑ kickstarter most funded MMORPG.png
  154. ↑ kickstarter most funded video game.png
  155. ↑ MMORPG.com's Best of 2017 Awards.
  156. ↑ Most Anticipated MMORPGs For 2018.
  157. ↑ 157.0 157.1 DualShockers’ Gamescom 2018 Awards
  158. ↑ MassivelyOP 2020 awards reader's poll.
  159. ↑ MassivelyOP reader's poll.
取自“https://ashesofcreation.wiki/index.php?title=Open_development&oldid=63287”